Showing posts with label Digital audit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Digital audit. Show all posts

Thursday, 5 November 2015

Have TalkTalk breached the Data Protection Act ? Certainly a possibility..........

With admirable gusto TalkTalk have answered the above question on their own website by saying "No, this is a criminal attack. We have notified the ICO and we will work closely with them over the coming weeks and months".

There we are - no need for any type of judicial system we can all simply decide for ourselves if we have complied with legislation.

In the real world (and given the sanctions from the ICO that TalkTalk has received previously) it is not likely to be as simple as that.

Principle 7 of the Data Protection Act states that "Appropriate technical and organisational measures shall be taken against unauthorised or unlawful processing of personal data and against accidental loss or destruction of, or damage to, personal data."

If reports are true that the attack on TalkTalk was based on SQL injection then, given that Input Validation methods will prevent this, a company the size of TalkTalk would not appear to have taken appropriate measures.

No doubt a commercial decision was taken somewhere within TalkTalk that the cost of defending against an SQL type attack was not justified and that the risk was acceptable.

The problem perhaps is that TalkTalk were trusted to keep customer data safe and had they asked the customer base to decide between staff bonuses or slightly better protection against having all their data stolen the decision would probably have been the latter.

Until we know the nature of the attack and whether appropriate measures had been taken to prevent it it is too early say if a breach has occurred.


Tuesday, 3 November 2015

Investigatory Powers Bill - are the politicians entitled to be trusted not to abuse power ?

The statement "War is a mere continuation of politics by others means" (von Clausewitz) illustrates that politics is a dirty business mainly about the pursuit of power. There are always exceptions but history shows a fairly consistent pattern with shameful incidents such as "weapons of mass destruction", IRA immunity letters, guantanomo bay  and such like. At a different level even highly respected organisations such as the RSPCA seem to have spun totally out of control when given too much power without effective checks and balances in place.

The current PR charm offensive seeks to blur the lines between the legitimate requirements of the Security Services and Armed Forces in the digital age and other branches of Government.

The forerunner to the Investigatory Powers Bill, RIPA, was sold in on the basis that the check and balance was the Investigatory Powers Tribunal which up until quite recently was so low key it made MI6 look like Graham Norton (sorry Graham) and has upheld only 10 cases since 2001. Go figure.

It is a terrible thing to give airtime to Joseph Goebbels (Hitler's PR man) but he pretty much sums it up;

“If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.”

Over the course of history the doctrine of the separation of powers between the legislative, executive and judiciary has been maintained to keep balance and prevent abuse of power.

Given how many Acts of Parliament, Statutory Instruments and sections of Common Law are currently "live" it is probably safe to say we are all guilty of something if you look hard enough for long enough.

It is therefore crucial that a signature from a judge is obtained before warrants are granted under the proposed Investigatory Powers Bill. This should reduce the extent to which the politicians and petty officials can target and destroy their enemies using these considerable powers. If the only remedy is an approach to the Investigatory Powers Tribunal we have a pretty clear idea already which way that one will go based on performances to date. Slip on the orange jumpsuit and prepare for the full cavity exam.

If national security is at risk there should be no problem securing a signature. Hopefully though the judges hand will pause if the real objective of the warrant is to help someone meet a budget target and keep their job or to destroy the reputation of a political enemy in the run up to an election.

If a politician is holding the pen I think it is clear what the outcome would be and how attempts would be made to cover it up. As Jean Claude Junker, President of the European Commission and "uber" politician in Europe famously said;

"I am for secret, dark debates.....when the going gets tough, you have to lie."

This is not an attack on politicians but a recognition that power needs to have independent checks and balances - we need judicial oversight.


Wednesday, 28 October 2015

Ensure your digital front door is not wide open

When any entity is attacked online it is quite common for accusations to be levelled at criminal gangs (presumably on a break from people trafficking).

Of course high level attacks are very sophisticated and are occurring regularly (see this free monitoring service from Google) but from direct experience in the IP piracy management space often the matter is much more mundane.

Companies leave the digital front door wide open and it is fairly likely that at some point someone passing by in cyber space will have a go. TalkTalk may prove to be a case in point if it turns out that the root of the problem was a 15 year old living with Mum & Dad using some freeware on page 1 of Google. The red faces in the security team at Talk Talk will not repair the damage done if, when the case come to trial, it becomes clear how easy it was.

A Digital Audit is a basic requirement now for all companies that use the internet. An independent double check that all is reasonably in order is vital given the multiple standards and skill levels that exist in the digital and IT security industries. Given that a Digital Audit can be obtained for less than £250 cost is not a barrier.

Inevitably one size will not fit all in this space but a minimum level of protection is a requirement for all companies who use email and the internet and manage digital IP.

Wednesday, 14 October 2015

Rear view (mirror) - cybercrime statistics and cord nevers

'When faced with a totally new situation,' McLuhan famously says, 'we tend always to attach ourselves to the objects, to the flavor of the most recent past. We look at the present through a rear-view mirror. We march backwards into the future.'

The announcement today that UK cybercrime statistics to be released on Thursday will show a massive jump - making them the biggest single grouping - is coming straight through the windscreen. Definitions are always a challenge but if file sharing etc was included in this then it is no real surprise. The gap in understanding has been caused by the time it takes to collect the figures.

Similarly the emerging data on cord nevers and cord cutting in the TV industry in the US makes sense given the ease of viewing pirate material from most major distributors nothwithstanding the technology that has been thrown at it.




Monday, 12 October 2015

Cord Nevers steaming into pay tv - by 2025 50% adults under 32 will not pay for TV

Some new research from James McQuivey of Forrester  suggests that by 2025 50% of adults under the age of 32 will not pay for TV.

He identifies a new group of cord-nevers who are in fact a larger group that cord cutters. On the face of it if armed with a high speed connection and some technical knowledge there is no need to subscribe to pay TV why would you ? This chimes with KLipcorp's less formal research which showed that 57% of people think that there is no need to subscribe to pay TV for sport due to the availability of pirate content.

The bloodbath in US Media stocks recently reflects a bundle of concerns regarding the shift to digital but possibly at its heart is the dawning realisation that control over distribution has been allowed to slip away. Anyone who has seen the fantastic new movie The Martian will agree that anything is possible given sufficient creativity and determination but the traditional distributors of media need to pretty quickly get a grip over distribution to avoid becoming candidates for the Darwin Awards.

A potential first step would be an independent Digital Audit to really identify the scale of current leakage and the adoption of a prioritised approach to fill the gaps.

The sector has a great fondness for machines that go ping but as in The Martian the thing that really saved Matt Damon at a key moment was a roll of gaffer tape.

Friday, 9 October 2015

Kim DotCom facing his Waterloo

Kim DotCom like Edward Snowden has his supporters and detractors. Some see both as battling a flawed system but what they have in common is that in all likelihood both have broken US law.

The law is often an ass and it is said that unjust laws cannot stand - but tell that to someone lounging around in Guantanamo Bay in an orange jumpsuit waiting for the snap of the rubber gloves.

Either way it looks like Mr DotCom is unlikely to escape the clutches of the US Legal system. He had been attempting to argue that since he had no funds left he was unable to afford to have any experts represent him in an extradition hearing. Therefore any hearing would be unfair.

The North Shore district court was not having any of this and the argument was made that since MegaUpload had been paying people to upload illegal material this was a straightforward matter where experts were not required.

The matter will rumble on and it looks likely that Mr DotCom will face the US Justice system in a very high profile case that is probably far from clear cut.


Thursday, 8 October 2015

Understanding Digital vulnerabilities

The digital age has swept up so quickly that necessary adjustments to processes and behaviour are lagging. The legal system and regulation has struggled to maintain relevance and behaviour that would never be accepted in the physical world is accepted at the moment in the digital space with a shrug of the shoulders.

For many individuals and businesses there is a need for a Digital Audit which in a simple and low cost way helps them to quickly understand key vulnerabilities and issues.

From a customer point of view the machine or process that goes "ping" is only helpful if it helps them identify or solve a problem in a cost effective way. All the hackers out there have access to very powerful freeware and in order to avoid leaving your digital front door open and inviting them in to party (and maybe turn your data into bitcoin) it is necessary to carry out a digital audit.

Data and intellectual property are increasingly the key assets of small to medium businesses and this needs protection.

Wednesday, 7 October 2015

Anti-piracy group BREIN wins key battle in the protection of digital IP rights - pirates personal & banking details to be disclosed by infrastructure operators

One of the challenges facing groups attempting to protect their IP rights in a proportionate way is that when a pirate website is taken down, domains are cancelled or similar the individuals involved simply set themselves up again.

Up to this point the providers of web based infrastructure such as Google, Akamai, PayPal etc would not reveal the details of the operators even if services were cancelled. Some operators promote "absolute privacy" as a benefit of their services. Therefore the work done to close the operations down can appear to have little real impact unless the individuals concerned stop carrying out pirate activities for other reasons.

In fairness with the Snowden revelations there is no doubt that the protection of privacy is crucial and that data should only be provided in an approved and transparent way. However a balance needs to be identified between allowing companies and individuals to protect their property and the rights of individuals who are abusing that property to protect their anonimity behind a veil of privacy.

In the snappily titled C / 09/492 901 / KG ZA 15-1085  the case concerned the unlawful sale of a large number of pirate e-books via Google Play. Google agreed to remove the relevant app but would not reveal the identity of the people running the operation on the grounds of privacy.

Clearly the Court viewed this as  jejeune (naive,simplistic and superficial) and gave it both barrels as  outlined below (translated by Google translate) 

The judge commands Google to within 3 weeks of this judgment to the counsel of BREIN in favor of BREIN, the following information, to the extent that Google becomes available, provide with respect to the holder (s) of the Google Play Books Partner Center Publisher Account (s) from which books were uploaded under the Google Play Books URL (s) that BREIN has logged in its request removal of May 19, 2015 (Google zaaknr 76,488,000,007,259.), as described in the body of the indictment:

With regard to the Publisher Account:
a. subscriber information;
b. the IP address of the computer that the Publisher Account is created;
c. billing information, ie, mailing address and bank account number, bank name and name of the bank account;

In the case of the Google account that was used to create the Publisher Account:
d. the date and time the Google Account has been created;
e. the IP address of the computer that the Google Account has been created;
f. IP addresses of the computers that the user has logged into the Google Account;
g. The secondary email address and the specified first and last name specified for the Google Account;

this under the condition that the person concerned has not within 14 days of the date of this judgment to Google objection raised with the aim to prevent the provision of this information to BREIN;
2.5.
explains the order given under 5.1 enforceable, but only insofar as it relates to the provision of data relating to addresses, bank accounts and IP addresses within the European Union;

3.5.
hold any further decisions, pro forma until Saturday, December 12th 23:00 h to give and another version, which date will be the first party to the court in writing or a follow-session agenda must be desnodig forthwith with all relevant prevented from attending, or whether the case can be dismissed or canceled in writing.

This is a key step forward in helping rights holders to protect their IP in the digital age.



Tuesday, 6 October 2015

Periscope and Meercat not material in the piracy debate

Much has been reported about the risks of individuals using Periscope and Meercat as platforms for pirate activity and the mass audiences it may attract.

Perhaps unfairly this really does bring to mind Benny Hills antics at the end of his great TV shows (go on listen to that theme here one more time) where he has no real idea what is going on.

Perhaps at some point in the future this might be an issue but right now any analysis of the piracy landscape shows 24/7/365 live streaming being carried out with some enthusiasm by the pirate community with the DMCA technology based solutions forming a latter day Maginot line with similar effectiveness levels.

Why would you bother with Periscope and Meercat when an App like the one below delivers fully produced pictures live and free ?






































No easy solutions here but Periscope and Meercat are a red herring (it was worth it) in the piracy debate.

Monday, 5 October 2015

Key points in the Digital Age & time for a Digital Audit

The digital age is considered to have started sometime shortly after 1945 (a subject really well covered in the excellent book Turings Cathedral)

However the pace of change did not "go large" until the internet came along in 1990's and started to disrupt some industries, such as TV & video based media, which had not themselves been around a long time.

Looking back the era of linear pay tv delivered by satellite to the home may be viewed with the soft nostalgia reserved for steam travel and valve amplifiers.


Recent data showing that this year, 181 million people in the US will watch video via an app or website that provides streaming content over the internet and bypasses traditional distribution (eMarketer) starts to show the pace of change.

For some the digital revolution has caught them somewhat off guard (Blockbuster for example) others have literally taken over the world - Google.

If OTT growth continues at this pace and is linked to cord cutting then many of the accepted truths about the media industry are about to get a solid going over. Maintaining control in the wild west of the internet is a very different proposition to the command and control approach adopted in pay tv.

Perhaps time for a Digital Audit to assess the risks and liabilities that are appearing over the horizon ? This is starting to look like the attempts by the phone companies  in the 90's to protect call revenues even after it was clear that the game was up.